Aadel Collection
Report submitted by Mr. Abdelfattah Amor, Special Rapporteur, in accordance with Commission on Human Rights resolution 1995/23
UNFTED NATIONS E Economic and Social i S i )ff# • • • Council GflI L E/clI.4/1996/9srndd.2 9 F b &w 1996 nIGLrH O igu l FpnIcI{ cct IS S ‘Oil Oil Rt 1I R IGIrr S Fifty- ;© d i© It 19 ©f th p © i i©: 1 &g d& ThrL rr T ‘Oil OF TI tCCUR T lOll Oil TI aL nrnT lOll OF MJ FOP1 S OF nrr OLEr 1ICE MID OF Dr CR fl fl T lOll S Oil Rfl IG lOll OR a t t( itt j by M . bj 1f&tt h Sç ,i&l R&çp fl with 0 i i© © W]! ! Ri ht 1, ti© 1995/2? Visit by th Sç ,i&l R&çp t t© th I 1 i frâi ©f cOlrr nrr S Thtj , ti ' 1 -4 I. LEGISL T 1011 flI TI F fl OF TOL MlCE MID 11011- DrCRL flrnT ‘Oil Oil Rfl IGIOilOR fl 5 -22 . 0 tit, ti©: 1 — ©fth Sçi&1R&pp t 5 -20 1. I 1 i it i& p © dd j f© by th I! i 0 tit, ti© 5 - 6 2. offi 1igi© 7 -9 4 Sit, ti© ©f i : '©=ti 10 -20 4 Oth 1 1 — th Sc i 1 R&pp fl - fr ' 21 - 22 6 GE.96—106?0 E)
E/clI .4/1996/95/ dd .1 colrrnrrs © t fl j) P &ct II. ThrL Tr T ‘Oil OF LEGISL T l oll MID P LICV flI TI F mn OF T OLEr 1ICE MID 11011- Dr CR fl flrnT ‘Oil S OilRfl IGIOilOR fl . 1?-95 7 . sit, &tfr ' ©f ligi© i © iti . 1?-5? 7 1. ll '- M 1j i © iti . 25-46 7 2. . 47 -5 ? 1 1 S it' &t fr ' ©th i it i . . . 54 - 95 12 1. Sit, 55 -70 1? 2. 71 -95 17 III . colIcrus 10112 MID RECC F lD T 10112 96 - 119 10
E/clI .4/l996/95/ dd .1 Tht j , ti ' 1. F 15 t© 11 t t 1995 th 2ç ,i&l R&pp t © th ti© ©f ligi© i t©1 & !i it t© th I 1 i R pth1i ©f I ! hi t, ©f &t th fl ,it&ti© ©f th I : 'i : ' 1 . H t© T h ! ' 15 t© 19 20 19 r ; t ) d I f& 21 t ) . I{ h d ,flt&ti© with ©f th & th© iti d ©f © iti d with & ©f di id , &1 . I{ th M i t f© F© ig ff&i th M i t ©f th t p] ty M i t ©f L &1 d Tht ti© 1 ff&i fl th Mfl i tw ©f F© ig ff&i th t p, ty M i t ©f i, &ti© . th t p, ty M i t ©f oflt, &1 ff&i fl th Mfl i tw ©f oflt, I 1 i th Di ;t© ©f th 0ffi ©f Mfl © ity ff&i fl th Mfl i tw ©f Oflt, I 1 i th p id t ©f th R , ti© w 0 t fl th Mfl i tw ©f d th t© th P id t 2i ligi© &ff&i I{ 1 © t with ligi© ,rn d p 1iti &1 p t&ti / ©f th ch i ti 1/ J i h Z t i d 2=1 © iti 11 with ©f th i . I{ 1 © t th p id t ©f th P& 1i t&w W]! ! Rights 0 itt d th I 1 i W]! ! Rights 0 i i© . I{ fl p i /&t with M . t U V&f i, M . 2h h p d F& & h© —t j ©f th ©f p t© — h 1d fl /fl p i= . I{ 1 © ;i it j ! y ©f hip. ( ity i ity h 1 Th 2ç ,i&l R&pp t 1d 1ik t© th !th th I! i th© iti f© h& 'fl g fl ,it j hli d &tt& h b 1i li pt t© this fi t ‘i it & 2ç ,i&l R&pp t © th ti© ©f ligi© Th this ,ti© . h th ff© t by th ©f I ! d it ihip t© ç &t with hli d' fl g hi I{ i 1 © g &t f ,fl t© th with h t p p fl g d kfl g th ‘i it 4. Th 2ç ,i&l R&pp t l© ly t , di i th it, &ti© with t© ligi© fr k fl th I 1 i R pth1i ©f I ! fl th light ©f 1 i 1&ti© fl th field ©f t©l d © -di ü ti© b i ligi© © t li f it pl t&ti© d p li i I . LEGISL T l oll f T TI F fl OF T0L 1ICE MID 11011- DrCRn frnT loll Oil Rfl IG ‘Oil OR a . O tit, ti© l p l i© d ©f th 2ç ,i&l Rp t 1. I 1 i it i& p © dd j f© by th I! i O tit, ti© 5. © dfl g t© &fli l 4 ©f th O tit, ti© , ll i il fu i l ,flt, &l iit&w. p liti &l d ©th d jU&ti© ‘ t t b j I l i it i&. This p fl ipl &ppli g &lly t© ll &fli l ©f th O tit, ti© , ll t© th ©th d jU&ti© d th f & ©f th @ d o: ]! il t k d,i i© fl this
E/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .2 p g 4 6. Th Sç ,i&l R&pp t id th&t h th d ffl 'iti© ©f I 1 i it i&. © th © —& ©f ligi© it i& th ©th . Th this =;ti© th & th© iti fl di &t j th&t t fl g t© th ©f I 1 i b j © th i1 ©f th c pl . They fl© © t th&t w 1 1 fl ti© , li p1i it1y, ©f th ligi© p fl ip1 ©f th &J© ity ©f th p p'fl&tfr '. cuth t© ligi© th g t p t&ti , id th&t it th d' ty ©f th St&t t© ight hi h pt ,t i by th O tit, ti© d by iti© ©f th right ©f fl © ity t© &pply ligi© t© ç l d ity &ff&i . It th&t I 1 ligi© ©f t© th 1 k ©f tit, ti©: 1 d ffl 'iti© ©f I 1 i it i&. it th&t th o tit, ti© t b1i h j d th d ffl j th p fl ip1 t&fl i th th! '. Th & th© iti && itt i th&t g &t p,i i© h fld t th © gh 1 i 1&ti© . 2. offi rn 1i i© 7. t© &ni 1 12 ©f th O tit, ti© . Th ©ffi rn 1igi© ©f I ! i I 1 d th d ;t fl th&t ©f th J& f& i h 1 Efl ] U1 &1-Dfl ' d fiqh ] d this p fl ip1 i1 t 11y Oth I 1 i h fl 1' dfl g th I{ fi, ShAfi i, I 1IXi, I{ !t 1i, d Z&ydi, & t© t f'fll d th fr f©11 & fr t© & t fl with th fr fl çf fl g th fr 1igi© it Th h fl J©y ©ffi rn fl &tt t© 1igi© i, &ti© . &ff&i ©f ç l t&t , &i&g , di ,, ih it , d i1 ) d 1&t j 1itig&ti© fl ©f Th ©f th © t w M 1i! f©11 fl g y ©f th h fl ©f fiqh tit , t th J© ity, j,fl&ti© ithfl ' th b d ©f th i di ti© ©f t© t fl with th h 1 ©f fiqh , itflt fl 'frfl gfl g th ight ©f th f©11 ©f ©th h fl 9. St fl g th&t th © pt ©f St t 1igi© i ©t fl it 1f t© h,]! ! ight th Sç ,i&1 R&pp t th&t th&t f& t ©t t &t th ©f th ight ©f ©th 1igi© . I{ ©t i th&t th t© th I &ii shiit d th U- -I{&gh M 1li ity fl 9. Th & th© iti fl di &t j th&t th o tit, ti© ©t &t&1 ©f 1igi© d th&t iti© ©f th ç ,i&1 t&t , ©f 1igi© d 1igi© iti ©t t flit t i di i &ti© &g&fl t S it' &t i ' ©f i it i 10. t© &fli 1 1? ©f th O tit, ti© , J i h d ch i ti I i th ©ay 1igi© © iti hQ ithfl ' th 1li it ©f th fr t© ç f© th fr 1igi© it d d t© t© th fr fl &tt ©f ç l &ff&i d 1igi© j, &t i© .
E/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .2 11. Th with &ni 1 14 ©f th a tit, ti© Th ©f th I 1 i R p] b1i ©f I ' 11 1j., & d] ty b: ]! d t© t &t fl © f© ity with Tflt b1 d th p fl ipl ©f I 1 i J , ti d Tty d t© th fr h,]! ! ight . This p fl ip1 &ppli t© 11 h© fr g&gfl g fl pfr& y © & ti !ity &g&fl t I 1 d th I 1 i R p] b1i ©f I !'. 12. fli 1 26 ©f th o tit, ti© p © id th&t Th f© &ti© ©f p t ,i ti p 1iti &1 © p ©f i© 1 & ,i&ti© & 11 & ligi© i ti h th I 1 i © © ©f th ligi© © iti i ç itt i. p © dd i th they d© ©t ,i©1&t th p fl ipl ©f fr k d &ti© 1 ity, th it i& ©f I 1 © th b i ©f th I 1 i R p b1i . lT© © y t p t i fr p i ip tfl'g fl th &f ti© i g © p © t ç ll i t© p i ip t fl th 1 ?. t© &fli 1 64 ©f th a tit, ti© , & t© t 270 ©f th lT&ti©: 1 a t&ti b1y. ft w 10 y & fl fl th p p,fl&ti© . p t&ti , i1 t dd i t© it , y &t th ©f 1 150 000 &ddit i© 1 . Th z©t i d i1 p t&ti / y i !' — ch 1d ! ch i ti i1 J©fl'tly p t&ti ' ch i ti fl th ©nh d th© fl th © th ©f th © t w i1 1 ;t © p t&ti / . If th p p]fl&ti© ©f th © iti &ft 10 y & they i1 t &dditi© 1 p t&ti© &t th &t ©f 1 150 000. R J,fl&ti© 1 ,ti© i1 t d t fl i by 14. fli 1 67 ©f th a tit, ti© 1&tfl g t© th th t k by ©f th lT&ti©: 1 a t&ti b1y p © id th&t th ©f ligi© © iti th fr h©ly b k 15. t© &fli 1 144 ©f th a tit, ti© , Th ©f th I 1 i R pth1i ©f I ! ‘ t t !‘ I 1 i I . . ( Itt j t© I 1 I Id 1 y d th c pl . d fl t© It h© f&Ith fl th ©bJ ©f th I 1 I R 1, tI© d & d ,©t j t© th & hI fl g It g l . flI 1 16? ©f th a tIt, tI© 1 © p © Id th&t Th © dItI© d IfI &tI© t© t fflfi1 i by & J' dg i1 t d t fl i by fl WIth th It I& ©f fiqh . 16. Th ply t© th Sç ,I&l R&ppt T t f© f , &tI© b t fl © Ity Ight th & th© ItI &tt tI© t© th Ight ©f © ItI p © Id i f© fl &flI 1 1? ©f th a tIt, tI© , ç ,I&lly th EIght t© hIp, lIgI© &tI© d f ily t &dItI© 11 th EIght t© p t&tI© fl P& 1 t &fl . 64 d 67 ©f th a tIt, tI©rn d th fr ©f th fr ,flt, &1 ,rn & t1 1t ithfl ' th d ffl j by th st&t . Th & th© itI ©ft ] j th p i 'il fl t© © itI p I 'fl& 1y th fr p t&tI© fl p& 1 t tflgh they fl th by th a tIt' tfr '. Th ply t© th Sç ,I&l R&pp T t f© b t th ©f th p i 'il th & th© itI Id th&t they Ight ©f © itI
E/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .1 17. cflth t© th ©f ©f © iti t© th & y d th di i&w. th M i t f© F© ig ff&i id th&t f© p 1iti &1 d &ti©: 1 d fl © d t© t ©f th 1©y<y ©f th fr ©ffi i fl 11 h d ç ,i&l f© t© pt fl th & y d t 11ig . Oth g t ©ffi rn id th&t th © di li i &ti© &g&fl t © iti fl ©f t© th 19. Th ply t© th Sç ,i&1 R&ppt b t th iti© ©f th th © iti t© fl &ni 1 1? ©f th o tit' t d th 1 k ©f ©ffi i 1 iti© ©f th i pi l& , it t&t i th&t th g ! t i t© th © iti ©]fld ©t t t d j t© 11 . It 1 © 11 j th&t 1 k ©f iti© did ©t ©f ight thE/clI .4/1996/95/ dd .1 p g 7 II. ThrL Tr T ‘Oil OF LEGISL T ‘Oil MID P LICV fT TI F fl OF TOL MlCE MID 11011- DrCRn frnT ‘Oil Oil Rfl IG ‘Oil OR a . 2it, &tfr ' ©f i j © it1 1?. Th 2ç ,i&l R&pp t th it, &t1© ©f th © it1 fl &n1 1 1? ©f th 0 tit, t1© 1 . . — d th&t ©f th s i M 1li fl © ity. 24. ch i t1 : th 2c ;i&l R&pp fl ] d fl ç ,if1 &11y with Ptt t fl © ity, fl ,t1© ©f this h&pt t it1 j 2 it] &t 1© ©f ©th M 1 i! i it 1 . 71 t© 95 t1 th it, &t1© ©f this ( ity i b 1 &1ly it diff t fr th&t ©f th ©th © it1 1. it ' - M 1 i! i it 1 25. Th hi ly i th 2ç ,i&l R&pp t bfl i th f , &t1© th J i h y ©-ch 1d ! d © it1 hil t kfl g t© fl t th ç ,if1 ©f © . t fl g hi i it h t 1 i t© ©bt&fl' f& t d f1 th © it1 fr th fr p t&ti / — th & th© it1 p 1 'fl& 1y th Off1 ©f Mfl © ity ff&i fl th Mfl i tw ©f oflt] d I 1 1 M © it 1 Thf© &t1© fr ©f i it 1 Thf© &t1© fr th Off1 ©f Mfl © ity ff&i 60 000 ?0 000 t© 40 000 th , t 1© 70 000) 40 000 — 50 000 200 000 15 y & — 000 t© ?4 000 20 000 25 000 b t 17 000 b: t 100 000 26. Th f1 p © 1d i by fl © ity p t&ti / — th & th© it1 it diff t p ©b b1y th © it1 f1 pp j t f© th 1, t1© . hil th & th© it1 &pç & t© t© ©ff1 rn p t&t1© &t th tli . Th diff th ©f l& g ©f ©f i it 1 f© ©th © t . Th i ity p t&ti , & ;1&t this 1g &t1© with , fl t th I !- d th diff1 ,flt ;© 1 c hil !‘y p t&ti , d© ©t d y th&t d p' t k pl& ‘flt ©f th I: 1 1, t1© — th t b1i t ©f I 1 1 2t&t they th&t di ,t1y by th b t &th , by f© 1g h1 h th 1 , t1© &ti 1y, p 1 'fl& 1y with t© th © it1 d ‘ g i th t©E/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .1 27. Th & th© iti th&t th ! y d p fl' by ©f © iti — by M 1i! . It t&t i th&t th it, &ti© ©t th ©f g t b t ©f ,©1 t&w d p' by y© h© id j th&t hi &ti© d 1' fld ©t t &d&pt j t© th p fl ip1 ©f th 1' ti© . 1' dfl g th ©f & Th it, &ti© th' did ©t &ff ;t © iti ©ay. 29. © dfl g t© ©ffi rn f, &ti© © iti d iti fl 1' dfl g th i ) & © t f© b t 1 ©f p p,fl&ti© ©f &J© ity ©f M 1i! b t 99 Shiit d 10 S] i ) & ) I ! ' th fi 1d U) R iqi©' p & ti d ©f iqi©, &ff&i 29. Mfl © ity ligi© p 1iti 1 d ,rn t&t j th&t they ©t thJ t i t© y by th th© iti fl th fr i t 1 ligi© & ti ,iti hi h ©,fld t fr 1y, p i 'fl& 1y with t© hip d ligi© t &diti© d th ©f th &ff&i ©f ligi© tit, ti© pt f© th Z©t i h© p= j tm i &1ly ©f ‘ fl g th fl © ity p t&ti , id th&t th ©f th l g, &g d, fl g ligi© ©,fld ©t t ©pti© © dfl'g t© th fr ligi© t &diti© , th l g, &g 1igi© t th&t ©f th fr ity © . g &l th fr © igu 1 tm 'i g © p. Th th&t ,ti© , th t p, ty M i t ©f Oflt, &1 ff&i fl th Mfl i tw ©f Oflt d I 1 i @ id id th&t th© © iti : t j t© th fr l g, &g f© 1igi© d th&t they h d t g ! t i th&t right by th & th© iti h© 1d ©bJ ;ti© t© th ©f if th i it i T t j it ?1. Th ,ti© with p © 1yti d th fl © ity p t&ti ; > 1 fl j th&t I 1 fl t t j by th I: i did ©t 11 th p © 1yti d © i© ©f M 1li th 1igi© d th&t they th 1 / y ©-Ch 1d !' — © iti ) did ©t g&g fl th© p & ti d did ©t ! t th th fr iti ç ,ifi 1igi© d tm i © iti d th fr 1igi© tit, ti© t© th fr ,flt, &1 d 1igi© id titi d. th' th fr J i h. d iti . Th © iti 1 © id th&t they t© p © 1yti — &tt pt t© / t th t© I 1 ii) R 1 i i© fl ' t ‘ t i ' Th fl © ity p t&ti / id th&t th t & hfl g ©f th i 1igi© — fl pthl i h 1 © t id h 1 h© th ©t © gh fl © ity hild f© 1igi© t ti© d fl h 1 . They th&t M 1li 1igi© t ti© © th d th&t th i 1igi© &ti© d & fl th h 1 p t R 1igi© t ti© byE/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .2 fl © ity &ti© 1 &ti© © paid by th © iti ) © th b i ©f tb k pp i d f d i by th Mfl i tw ©f &ti© fl ç &ti© with th © iti . Th tb k 1&t t© th t & hfl g ©f th ligi© ©f th fl © ity fl ti© d fl© © ©th ligi© d th fr p fl ip1 . Th id th&t they fld 1ik t© t fl 1 i fl th pp &ti© ©f tb k © t&fl 'fl g f , &ti© t© 11 ligi© uji) R 1i i© pai &ti© Th fl © ity p t&ti , th&t 11 pth1i &ti© h© th &, th© t( itt j t© th & th© iti f© ifi &ti© & thi &tfr '. c hil i fl g th&t this p; j] did ©t &pply ©ay th they b t it © t hi h ,flt i fr th t ! 1&t pth1i &ti© © igu lly itt fl th fr fl © ity l g, &g fl't© d th t ©f ti: t© ©bt&fl ©ffi i 1 &pp © &l . Th p t&ti , id th&t this &ppli t© 11 I : 'i : ' iti d fl t d i p li & ily t© f© ligi© d p t y &tt pt t© ligi© 1 , . Th & th© iti fl© 11 j th&t th fld t ib t fu i&11y t© th pth1i &ti© ©f ligi© i /) p1& ©f hip • Th fl © ity p t&ti , id th&t they h d © gh ©f hip d th&t they fld /&t th d b ild • P1& ©f hip fi j by th iti th ©f hip 1& ifi j hi t© i &1 th st&t p © id j fü i 1 &i t f© th fr © ;&ti© fl th ©f th V k ch, h fl I f& d th z t i t p1 ©f f i fl v& d. Th © iti id th&t ©f hip h d t 1© j ©t ©f fr th & th© iti b t th ©t hipç fl i1&g fl g t© th ©f © iti cflth t© t© th ©f hip ©f © ; t j 1j.! th © iti &ffi , i th fr piti© p © 1yti d © i© R 1igi© p t © d] t ©f ligi© &ff&i • 29 t© ?1 b ) b) Th th waiti &1 fi 1d Th fl © ity p t&ti , th&t they h d p t&ti / fl p&fl t fl with &ni 1 64 ©f th o tit, ti© . Th M i t f© F© ig ff&i p fl 't i © t th&t th © iti h d p t&ti / tflgh they did ©t 11 ply with th 1 id & by th O tit, ti© , p t&ti f© 150 000 • Th this =;ti© th & th© iti id th&t th ight ©f fl & g &t th th© ©f M 1i! fl ©th p i 'fl& 1y D©ç ! • Th fl © ity id th&t it b1 t© © t ity p 1iti &1 & ti ,iti ‘ h th &ti© ©f th 1915 hi h i 1 b &t j 24 p il w y & by & th© i i d ©t &ti© 50 000E/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .1 p g 10 ) I ! ' th ,i©- 1t, &1 fi 1d Th fl © ity p t&ti , th&t & t© th O tit' t© . th th fr right t© &pply th fr ligi© fl ©f th fr ç l &ff&i &i&g , ih it , . th fr ( ity &ff&i . It t&t j th&t it h d h d t© t d ;id j h th it &pp ©p i&t © 1 f,fl f© th Sh& i & t© t &pp1i i t© - M1i.! f© flfl g by pth1i fli t i with © ity 1igi© Th th @ d_ o: ]! il h d U j fl th © ity Th I 1 i p fl ip1 t b1i h i by th I! i fl =;ti© fl 't with th I 1 i th p &ti© ©f th f© & ti ;iti d th p ©hThiti© 1 ©h©1 ‘] pti© &PPly t© © iti fl pth1i 1if . © dfl g t© th fr t &diti© d 1 , © iti pt fr th p fl ip1 fl p i ;&t 1if i 1' dfl g th h d ity . This hy th & th© iti p ©hThit t© ity by M 1i! h© t© ©t y th p fl ip1 ) pt ç ,i&1 ‘ h p tfl g ;i©-1t] &1 & ti ,iti © iti ity d flt, &1 f© < pl ) — h& it b1 & ,i&ti© h h© pit&fl ) hi h they fi th 1 / . Th t p, ty M i t ©f Oflt, &1 ff&i fl th Mfl i tw ©f oflt, — I 1 i @ id t&t j th&t th & ti ,iti =i j © t t i t i1y ithfl ' th f k d fI i by th St&t . P&ti ,fl& &tt ti© t© th & ti p fli ip ti© ©f © iti fl th ,flt, &1 fi 1d p fl tfl g. th &t ) d th fr k y t ib ti© t© th I! i h it&g ©f hip 1& ifi i hi t© i &1 © t ) . Th & th© iti 1 © © &g pth1i &ti© fil d di© d t i i© © © iti d th fr d 1igi© fl ,ti© with d© by 1j.! d - M1j.! 40. Th by th & th© iti d © iti 1igi© pth1i &ti© 1 © &pply t© pth1i &ti© fl g &l . M © iti tli p ©b1 th t t ©f th fr pth1i &ti© th© ©f hi t© i &1 &t] 1&t t© iti i] ] h th © i© ©f M 1i! t© th ligi© . d) Th th fi 1d ©f &ti© 41. Mfl © ity hild pth1i h 1 d fl © ity h 1 ç i i by th Mfl i tw ©f i, &ti© , hi h , p i 1 d fi ! &ti© 1 &ti© t&ff d h 1 tb k 1' dfl g ligi© t ti© t b k . M © iti hi h th 1 1 ©f th b ildfl g fi th ©f d t k p t fl th p h& d ©f h 1 T ip t th © gh p i ,&t d© t i© d d© t i© fr p t 1igi© tit, ti© 42. Th I 1 i it i& 1&tfl g t© th d th p &ti© ©f th &pp1i b1 b] t this th i © iti i© p ©b1 th h 1 t 1© g t© th fl p fl ipl . Th J i h fl © ity ! t i thE/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .1 p g 11 s bb th t© t fl it h 1 with p 1 t&w &pp © &l d pit th ©bJ ;ti© ©f T t fr th Mfl i tw ©f j, &ti© . p fl fr d' fl g th !i it th di ,t© ©f th h 1 t© t t© th ©f th © iti h© d© ©t ©bJ ;t t© th ©f . p.11 th p ©b1 t© di i© © iti — & th© iti d &i th ti© h th ‘ h h 1 h fld t pth1i p i /&t th © iti fld 1 ik 4?. cflth t© i iti f© &ti© t© p ©b1 ©f f© i ity © . pp1i: t t© i iti & © th fr ligi© k 1 ig . Th i & h fr ©f &t th ity ©f ) I ! ' th p ©f i© 1 fi 1d 44. Th &dditi© t© 1 k ©f t© g t pt © iti d© ©t p ©f i© : 1 t© th & y d th J] di i&w i t &ti©rn V & 1li it i fl th fr dç t t© th ©f th pti©: 1 . Th th p i '&t ;t© i © iti d© ©t y p ©b1 pt fl ç ,ifi d ç l ©t ,t i with th & th© iti . ©f g y h©p fl di &t th fr ligi© &ffii&ti© th fr© t ©f th fr h©p f) oth fi 1d 45. Th th fi 1d ©f Jti . ç ,i&lly &t th 11 ©f pth1i fl © ity pl&fl'tifft , , &lly di ü t i &g&fl ' t by J, dg h© th ©f fl © ity d ©t I! i iti &pplyfl g th fr b d ©f I 1 d t kfl g di i© th&t ©ft fl fi /© ©f 1j.! 46. Th t© th ti© ©f © iti th fl © ity p t&ti , th f©11 fl g f& t they d© ©t ! t th fr it, &ti© t© t &g&fl t th d ip,fl&t i by ©th f© th&t ©thfl g t© d© with th ‘ h p 1iti &1 t &t i &g&fl t They ph& i j th li pt d ©f th di 1 © iti d & th© iti ©f hfl g h©t-t , ji -t , d 1© g-t , d 1, ti© . They 1 © T t i th&t th fr it' &t h fld t d &1t with ©bJ ;ti 1y &t th flit ti© &1 1 1 2 . S i M 1 i! i ity 47. Th Sç ,i&l R&pp t b1 t© ©bt&fl' ©ffi rn fi th ©f th 2i fl © ity. Th 2i p t&ti / t_ th&t they b t 10 ©f th I! i p p,fl&ti© . &) I ! ' th fi 1d 49. Th 2i p t&ti / id th&t they ©t thJ t i t© fl th f© ©f t i ti© by th & th© iti ©f th fr ligi© & ti ,iti . They &tt ti© t© th fr t&t , l &llyE/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .1 p g 11 fl © 1ty d t© th 1ght d 1 'fl g fr 1t1© , & p © 1d i f© fl &fl1 1 1? ©f th O t1t, t1© . fl p fr k t© g i h1p t© th fr ligi©' t & hi g d 49. Th 2i t&ti 1d th&t th fr igi©' i ç ,if1 &11y !it i t© th fr t 11 ft d th&t f© &t1© © ©th ligi© fl© p © 1d j. Th t p] ty M i t ©f &t1© 1d th&t 2=1 t k p fl fl th p &t1© ©f ligi© t tb k 50. cflth t© pl& ©f hip th 2ç i&l R&pp t th&t th © 21 fl tflgh th 21 tty fld 1ik t© fi th t t1© ©f 1t pl ©f hip. ©f th&t it, &t1© . 21 hipç t© & P i t i h 1 d & 2&, di 1th fl f© . Th t p] ty M i t ©f 11 j th&t & © dfl'g t© I 1 y M 1i fld p &y fl y M 1i pl& ©f hip h th h 2hiit 2=1 © ©f th d ü t1© . Th t p] ty M i t ©f L &1 d Tht t1 &1 ff 1 1d th&t th 1 1 p ©hThit1 th t t1 ©f 2=1 ©f hip th&t th 2=1 f fl fl d th&t it h d © diffi ,flty fl p &yfl g fl 2hiit 51. R f i g t© i f ,&ti th&t 2i pl& ©f hip h d &11 fly t dt ©y i fl l rft d p fl ©f ‘ b dç t th 2i p t&ti / — th th© iti fl di &t j th&t & di i© h d t h 1d t© h th it h d t It fu 11y t] j © t th&t th h d t b] t th&t th pl t© b] ild . Th th© iti 1 © ©ff 1 d f© th t ti ©f 2=1 Th p t&ti , id th&t 2hiit — 2i fl I ! h d t d t ©y i f© th g i ©f th p p,fl&ti© p fl ©f dç t pl d th&t th 2i tty h d ! y i 52. Th t© th P id t 2i ligi©' &ff&i ph& i th&t th © ligi© © fli t 2hiit d d id th&t th p ©b1 ©f , ggli! g ! d t © i I! . H &tt ti© t© th ©f ,flt &- f ti 2=i p ©b1 th&t &ff ;t j 11 igi ' . I{ 1 © id th&t th © pi i© &g&fl t th ç ,i&lly ©f th fr 1©y<y t© th Th ©ffi rn p t&t 1 , id th&t they did ©t ! t th 2i ti© t© t p 1iti &1 &g&fl t oth fi 1d 5?. Th 2=1 t&ti th&t th did ©t !w t& 1 by th th© iti fl th p 1iti &1 ,i© - ,flt , &1 &ti© 1 p ©f i© 1 ©th fi 1d . . 2it, &ti ' ©f ©th © iti 54. Th 2ç ,i&l R&pp t &tt ti© t© th it, &ti© ©f both th i d th ptt t .E/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .2 p g 1? 1. 2 it' &t fr ' ©f th 55. Th Sç ,i&l R&pp t ©ffi rn fi th ©f th I Ity. I p t&tI , — ©th -g t&1 b I t &t th ©f I fl I : &t ?00 000 hI h I &lly th th 1& g t fl © Ity fl &) I ! ' th fI 1d I ) R ; It I ©f 1 i I© i Ity 56. Th & th© ItI t&t j th&t they d© ©t th I lIgI© fl © Ity. Th I g I &tI© t d fI i p 1ItI &1 ,t hI t© I &11y 1flth i t© th Sh h i! d, ! t - 1, tI© w d h & t I i by It pI© &g & tI ,ItI f© th t fit ©f f© Ig tItI p I 'fl&fly I & 1 . t fl g hI th Sç ,I&l R&pp t ©t i &1 © t tfl tI WIth t© th I Ity. 57. Th & th© ItI fl dI &t j th&t ©ay th lIgI© dIg It& I fld d Id th p ThiIty ©f g !‘tfl'g lIgI© fl © Ity t&t , t© th I . th g ! t i t© lIgI© © ItI fld ©t t t d j t© 11 . =- ItI© ©f th&t t&t, ala Ig Ify d p I ,&tI© ©f Ight . Th th&t WIth th ptI© ©f th I g I &tI© d fI i th & th© ItI p fl t i © t th&t I t fIt i fr 11 th EIght ©f I! I It pI 'fl&fly th EIght t© fr k ©f t 1I f, d, t© th o tit , t© fld t &tt& k j f© hI ©pfl 'I© d th Ight ©f ItI t pt ,t i ©f th I d I tI© . Th I p t&tI , ftt j th & &tI© aI ;t j &g&fl t th I g I &tI '. They p fl t i © t th&t t© th f d t&1 p fl Ip1 ©f th I lIgI© , I h fld 1©y<y d ©t jI t© th I d h fld fr y p 1ItI &1 Th I fl dI &t i th&t th & &tI© ©f pI© &g fl ©f I© I b j ©l ly th f& t th&t th I 1d fl . They p fl 't j © t th&t thIs t b1I h j © c 1 fl th 1& t t f© th t b1I t ©f th st t ©f fl WIth th 1I It t tI© ©f 1 'fl1 h th f© ! a ©f th I f&Ith. h© h d 1I i th fl E/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .2 p g 14 th I tI© , i 1' dfl g th tIp,fl&tI© th&t th t k by th &g&fl t th I h fld t dIg i t© ©b t t th fr 1' tI© — dç t 59. Th th lIgI© fI 1& th I p t&tI ; d ©th © -©ffI rn ©t i th&t th EIght t© p ©f d p tI th I f&Ith h d t d I j. Sfl 199 ? th I g I &tI h d &pp t1y t p ©hThIt by th & & ©f hI h th I h d t d I i th EIght t© — t© 1 ;t — ©c &t tIt, tI© . Sfl' . by ‘Ifl' ©f It f d t&1 p fl Ipl th I f&Ith h d © l gy. thE/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .2 p g 15 ) I ! ' th &ti©: 1 fi 1d 6?. Th t p, ty M i t ©f &ti© id th&t f© th d fl h©1 & ti ,iti th ©ay © diti© f© &ti . I{ fl di &t i th&t by th i t© high &ti© h fld ©t p ©b1 p © id j th&t th i did ©t fl ]! t th fr t 1i ft fl &ti©: 1 tit, ti© . Th i p t&ti ; ph& i i th&t 1990 fl]! g i h d t y t &ti &11y fr high &ti© 1 tit, ti© . E © i© ©f th t d& d ©f &ti© i© ly &ff ,tfl g th i ity. Th di,ti , ©f th oflt, &1 O: ]! il ©f th R 1' ti© th 1 1 ©f i, &ti ©t j: Th y ©1 fl h 1 p © id j th&t they d© ©t th fr i id tity. P f b1y, they h fld ©1 fl h 1 with t © g d 1igi© id 1 y. They h fld t fr th i iti ith &t th ti, ©f th & i i© d , fl g th i & it t =( &pp t th&t they & i . Th i p t&ti / fl di &t j th&t fl with th f d t&1 p ip1 ©f th fr f&ith they did ©t g&g fl p © 1yti b t if ti© i, 1d & k 1 ig th i 1igi© &ffii&ti© d ©,fld gi th i f&ith. d) Th th p ©f i© 1 fi 1d 64. Th i h© i t i i id th&t they t © g1y di i t i &g&fl t fl th fi 1d ©f p1© t . i h d © p=t fl th ]]u they t© I 1 . Th fr did&t, 1d t J ;t j they fi1 j fl th ti i fl hi h 1igi© &ffii&ti© h d t© t ç ,ifi i. fl th & ly b t 10 000 i h d &pp t1y t di i i fr th i pt fl th d fl th t & hfl g p ©f i© ©f th i 1igi© f&ith. l y h d J©b1 d itflt p1© t t fit . Li © l© g paid t© i h© h d t di i i f© 1igi© s h© h d t di i j fr th i p=t h d t T i j t© th ci i i. fr th Mfl i tw ©f u b: ! d S ,i&1 ff&i lT©. 20?61. d&t j 16/9/1?60 .H.) tip,fl&t j th&t: Th ç 1ty by th© h© t 1© g t© y ©f th i g id i i j by 11 1j.! h ti &1 i&ti© fr I 1 g i &ti© h© d tit , ti© ©f th di 'fl 1y- 1igi© h 11 t di i &1 fr pth1i ©ffi . . . d 1 © fr g i &ti© th&t t g t&1 © ©ffi 65. Th th p i /&t t© , th i 1 © i© ly &ff ,t i. Th th 1990 th 1i ©f i td h d t ithd & d th ©f g i by i h d t fi &t i. Th fi &ti© ©f c © l p ©ç fly &pp1i i ©t ©ay t© d b t 1 © t© &g i 'flt' &1 p ©ç fly. h d 1 © t fl th p i /&t ;t© with t© ,‘ fl g th di i &1 ©f i pl©y d 1 © &g&fl t i &g i 'flt' &1 . Th i ity th f© fl & t&t ©f d t i&1 ,, ity. 66. Th th© iti fl di &t i th&t ©b t& 1 pl& i fl th &y ©f i fl th p ©f i© 1 fi 1d d y ç 1ty ti ,&t i by i1 1E/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .1 p g 16 & ti ,iti ‘ h & pi© g . 11 t© pth1i ©ffi diti© 1 © th fflfil t ©f fl&fl ' it i&. ‘ h & 1©y<y t© th ) I ! ' th fi 1d ©f l' ti 67. Th I p t&tI , tI© i th higray &tI &ttIt, d ©f J' dI I&1 b jI t & d th I . Th f& t &p n fr pt I© : 1 th J , dI I&w 1d pItI 1y t© p1&fl t l ig i by I . Th p ‘ ppfl'g th I t© t fl /©1 i fl pI© &g & tI ,It I 1d fl f th&t th I h d Ight . Th E 1 O i 1 © d I i th I y Ight . F© th 1& t th y & th I h d nh 1 t tIt1 j t© ©f th ©f & & © dfl'g t© th I d th &t t© th t© y I 1I t . Th th ©f I T t by ! 1 f© fil © &lly J ;t j d th t t ©f ©t I &t j. 69. Th Mfl I tw ©f Id th&t dI i &t©w t &t t h d t p t i fl th J' dI I&1 ,t© . It fl dI &t i th&t J' dg h d th EIght t© & p1&fl t d J , tI fl WIth th l &lly p I 'fl& 1y f© th EIght ©f d th p ThiIty ©f &pç &lfl g d t fl g g ! t i f) S ;] Ity ©f 69 . Th I p t&t I ; Id th&t i 1979 101 p h& I h d t i t i — 15 ©th h d t p t i p ']! i 1990 t© Jfl 199? 4? I h d t t j — t© t ©f ©f th fr t 1I ft . s ; I d t&fl i d t ©f th h d t t© d &th th M . X&y ! a 1&J h dI — M . MIth&qI. tI© j fl th I© ©f 19 ‘ t 1994 fr th Sç , I 1 R&pp fl E/cIT .4 / 1995 / 91 p &. 64) . r fl g hI ‘I It th Sç ,I&l R&pp t h d t© th© t . ThIs ©t t . th I p t&ti ; ph& I i th&t d' fl g th 1& t i < th ©f I t i ©f th I lIgI© f&Ith h d d 1fl i d th h d &pp t1y t h&1t i. 70. Th Mfl I tw ©f th&t I t j d d t&fl j ©f ©ff i u 1 ©f pI© &g . . — ©t ©f th I t 1I ft . It p fl 't j © t th&t fr k( ©f t 1I f 1' di! g fr k t© &d©pt th lIgI© ©f © c l h©I , © &tt& k © ©th f&Ith fl th lIgI© & th I i. Th & th© ItI fl dI &t i th&t th f& t ©f t 1© gfl g t© th I Ity dId ©t t&il 1© ©f th Ight t© hI h I! I ItI tIt1 i. They 1 © Id th&t they h d h d t© t t 11 g © p th&t h d &1 &dyE/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .1 p g 17 1. Sit, t ©f th ptt t & ) I ! ' th fI 1d U) R ItI ©f P t t t IqI©' & I&tI 71. t© th f© &tI© th It, &tI© ©f th P©t t t lIgI© & ,I&tI© fl ©f ©ffI rn ItI© . pI 'fl&fly th© WIth tmu d © y I ) & l &lly hil th© Itflt y dI t tI© bflU! g y © -cr 1d ! I d M 1j dIffI 'fltI fl ©bt&flU! g 1 1 ItI© ©f th fr F© < pl th mth,1 ch, h ©t t th R 1' tfr '. Th ©b t& 1 t© t 1flth j t© th f& t th&t th© fl t tI© 1 — g &l ©t t I t j & ç ,IfI tmd g © p ?JU! g t© It Id tIty. O th th© Pt t t & ,I&tI© g© t y© d th tmu fl © d &tt & t 11 ©f ,I ty. 1' dfl g M 1i! h© MIght © / fl J©fl th© & ,I&tI© . Th p t&tI , ©f th© h©ç th&t th & th© ItI i1 h biIt&t th fr & ;I&tI© UI) R 1IqI©' ti ,itI d ©f hip 72. Th it, &tI© ©f th P©t t t tI© i by th & th© itI < pl ©f th it, &tI© ©f th ch i tI fl © ity hI h J©y th Ight d & ,I&t i with th&t t&t, d hI h & ©t bJ t t© y t I tI© ©th th th© p © Id i f© by 7?. Th Pt t t p t&ti , Id th&t th fr lIgI© & ti ,itI t© t I t I© . cuth t© lIgI© pth1I &tI© 1' di! g th they p fl t j © t th&t th Th1 S ,I ty ©f I ! h d t 1© j 1990 d th G d ©f / g li h d t fl it, &tI© JUy 1999. They ph i i th&t th ©f Th1 u d T &t f© th fr g &tI© d th&t t I tI© pl& i 11 lIgI© pth1I &tI© . Th ©f Th1 p ©hThit i d 20 000 ©f th lT Tt t fl hI h h d t © fi &t j fl S pt t 1991 h d ©t t cflth t© pl& ©f hip &tt tI© t© th ©f th t p1 ©f l u d 1999) S& i 1999) X h h d 1999) U992) d U992) . ©ay © ?JUy lIgI© & th i i &t th t p1 &t 74. Th g &tI© d p I 'fl& 1y th M 1li ©/ t t© d 1© with t© d' i! g th t© h ! d© th fr lIgI© & ti ,itI i 1' dfl g li pl lIgI© p & tI fl Id th fr t p1 . th © pt t t h d t fr th & th© itI l© g t© fl d l© g 11 M 1j =t t© t k p n . d' fl g di I© with th & th© it I Pt t t p t&ti / th hy they ©, 1d d© th&t . Th St. E t -©1-S&1t h ch, h fl th c t &1 b1y ©f j ch, h fl d th b1y ©f j ch, h fl R& ht 11 j t© fl Th with d d y I ) ©ffI I&t fl th l g, &g ©fE/cIT .4/1996/95/ dd .2 p g 19 th ity i. Th ©th © t id & ©t t© th l g, &g d ©t t© & pt M 1li ©/ t 75. © dfl g t© -g t&1 th p ti© ©f M 1li t© &t 1 & t 15 000 fl th Pt t t iti <flgh & ©f l© g t dfl g , i b t fl 1 d tfl &y. g &l fl th light ©f th fr t t&ti© ©f I 1 th & th© iti p ©hThit 11 f ©f p © 1yti d © i© ©f M 1j t© th ligi© , d this th 1li it&ti© pl& i © th ligi© & ti ,iti ©f th Pt t t d th © t i ti© t© hi h ©f hip t 76. cflth t© h' h p ç fly , fl ] h th&t ©f th Imi ,1 ch, h , th & th© iti h d © fi &t j p ©ç fly p t h© pit&1 fl t it] t f© th bl fl d h 1 t' d t h© t 1 i th R 1, ti© d h d b th 77. th pt t t p t&ti , th&t th th© iti h d t© th it' &t fl ç ,i&lly th ©f th pt t t p t© rih J H p d Mi h& 1i . Th p ti th t i ti© © ‘ t & / 1 © t id I : h d &pp t1y t 1ift j f© pt t ! 't b) Th ©th fi 1d 79. Th &dditi© t© th ç ,ifi it, &ti© ©f Ptt t fl th ligi© fi 1d, th 1&tt 1 © f&th! g th it, &ti© p t i fl th ©f th i i ligi© © iti p i 'fl&fly fl th &ti© 1 p ©f i©: 1 d J , di i&1 fi 1d S ;] ity ©f 79. r fl g hi ‘i it th Sç ,i&l R&pp t ©t j th t &'] &ti th ch i ti d pt t t iti by th ©f th pt t t p t© fl 1994: th R . T&t /© Mi h& 1i tfl g P id t ©f th o: ]! il ©f pt t t ch, h ©f I th R . hdi rih J M i t ©f th ch, h ©f th b1i ©f d th R . I{&ik H p p id t ©f th O ]! il ©f , g li &l ©f I ! d S , t& y - ©f th ch, h ©f th b1i ©f j th ] g t &pç &l ©f g t 1994 d th i &ti© ©f 19 1994 t© th I! i th© iti by th Sç ,i&l R&pp t fl hi p , ifl g p t E/clT .4/1995/91, p & . 6?- 65) 90. Th Sç ,rn R&pp t b1 t© ç k fr 1y f© &1 © t fi h© t p i © with th th h& g i with &idfl g d 1 ttfl g fl ] d : F& & t U V&f i I<&1&t h d Sh hp . Th h© p &t 1y , id th&t they t 1© g i t© th _jfl' g i &ti© d f© th ©f p t© Mi h& 1i , hi h th&t g i &ti© h d © d j with t© t ikfl g b1 &t th I! i St&t , hi h th flit ti© &1 ity 1d © d f© th© . They 1 © fl di &t i th&t th ©f p t© rih J d H p h d t ( itt j by th it ©f th h ifl g i &ti '.E/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .1 p g 19 91. Th & th© iti th&t & k l ig i th t &] &ti by th ©f th pt t t d t© th th&t h d t t k t© p ©t ;t ch i ti ©f ligi© . They &tt t fr t© th ig&t fr th&t h d t ,]]d fl k th© d t© th T t & t d t i&1 ©f th h© h d t t© t ©f li p i . They ph& i j th p Thiity ©f th h ifl g i &ti© , fl t f© th i ti© ©f p t© d f© th b b &tt& k © th l rft d They th© & t & & & ft11y pl i pfr& y &g&fl t th I !d St&t — &tt pt t© tfr ‘ p di © d — t&g 'i th tm i — 1 igi© i 92. Th M i t f© F© ig ff&i ph& i i th f& t th&t fl th ©f p f, th flit ti© &1 ity h fld ©t h©ld I ! d, fl p ni l& h fld ©t © d it f© th© . & t© i t &t th (t t ©f th flit ti© 1 ti© t© th ©f th th p t© fl t & t t© th &ttit, d &d©pt j t & d th ©f M 1li ligi© di it& i &ft th R©1' ti© . 9?. S ©f -g t&1 b ii tflght th&t th I! i St&t , & tfl g th © gh g © p h d © d i th ©f th pt t t p t© . They p fl 't j © t th&t R . DTh J h d t p i © j 1996 th&t I 1 i 1] ti©: w © t &t S& i h d hli t© d &th © 21 t t 199? f© pt y f©11 fl g hi © i© t© ch i ti ity l© g &g© fl 1949 th&t th ©] n h d 11 j ç i i ©f 20 d&y g & f© &pç &l &g&fl t it di i© d th&t R . DTh J h d t fr th flit ti© &1 ity th&t h d t &1 t i by R . H pi © 1? 1994 tflgh th & &ti© &g&fl t hli h d ©t t ithd & '. O fl g R . H pi it p fl t i © t th&t h bi t i i < d&y &ft th ©f R . DTh J d th&t h h d pth1i ly hi ©ppiti© t© th d &th ç 1ty t© hi h th 1&tt h d t R . Mi h& 1i h d T tly th p id y d ©f th O: ]! il ©f Pt t t ch, h ©f hi h th b iy & ity i tfl'g p tly ©f 1li ©/ t h© 94. t© th f, &ti© i i, th I! i h d &pp t1y d id i t© th© Pt t t fl © d ©t ©ay b fl g th h ifl g i &ti© fl t© dmp, t by d,1& fl g it f© th© b t &t th d ti 1 1 p tly d ,&pit&t th Pt t t ity d f© it t© di © tfl ', th © i© ©f M 1i! hi h &pt& y d th f© p ©hThit i t© th t t&ti© ©f I 1 . It &pp t1y f 1t th&t th© I 1 th I 1 i R pth1i ©f I th&t 1d th t i ti© j p j fl th ligi© fi 1d. 11 th ©f th ©f th Pt t t ity. pti ,fl& , p t© DTh J d hi ll &g, h d &pp t1y t fl ©t t© © &g th Pt t t ity, th © gh th ©f p t© rih J t© tfl ” it i ' & ti ,iti 95. ©f -g t&1 b ii 1 © th t rn ©f th th ©f th t , ty ©f J, ti d fl di &t i th&t th© h d ç t t1y di ,i&t i th 1 / fr th h ifl g i &ti©E/clI .4/1996/95/ dd .1 p g 20 t© &y th&t th© 1 © &g t ©f th St&t h© h d ifi i fl th 1&tt © t© th ç 1ty li p i fld ©t & t' &11y t &pp1i i © fld ©t t ©f l© g d, &ti© '. III. colIcLUs ‘O IlS MID RECC F ID T ‘Oil s 96. Th Sç ,i&l R&pp t id j ©t ©ay th 1 i 1&ti© fl th fi 1d ©f t©1 d © -di ü ti© b i © ligi© © t 1i f, h&p. I ©f this p t) b] t 1 © th p1 t&ti© ©f th&t 1 i 1&ti© ' d th p li y fl h&p. II ) . I{ 1y j th it, &ti© ©f th ligi© © iti - d 21 - . N d 1 © th&t ©f th © iti ly th i d th ptt t 97. P f© p tfl g hi d , d&ti© th© © iti fl this fü 1 h&pt . th Sç ,i&l R&pp t t© th&t d' fl g hi i it h & i &ti© , &t th it' &t ©f th G !'d y&t©11 h R ft i hi J& ,&d R©]ft ! 'L &t h i ti1 itfl g & ply fr th & th© iti 99. cflth t© th 1 i 1&ti© th Sç ,i&l R&pp t fl di &t j th&t & St&t ligi© i ©t fl it 1f, fl ti© with h,]! ! ight this ©f &ff&i - hi h i &t j by th I !d O tit ' t - h fld ©t t 1©it i &t th ©f th ight ©f © iti d th ight & ,i&t i with iti hip, hi h li p1y th&t iti h fld ©t t di ü t i &g&fl t © g © d ‘ h & fl t ligi© © t 1i f. F this t dp fl t th © pt ©f I 1 i it i& & t f©nh fl &ni 1 4 ©f th O tit, ti© h fld t p ;i ly d ffl j fl © 1 1 t t itnt gi 'fl g t© di i &ti© © g iti 99. cflth t© th it, &ti© ©f th © iti f© fl &fli 1 1 ? ©f th O tit, ti© . th Sç ,i&l R&pp t t© ph i th&t it h fld t l & ly d t i th&t h&t & & ih t ight ©f © iti ©t th&t t g t i. O fl g p ©f i© 1 by ©f © iti t© th & y d th J] di i&w & t . 104 d 16? ©f th o tit, ti©rn th sç ,rn R&pp t th&t 1 i 1&ti tt j,fl&tfl g th fl g &l h fld p ©hThit di li i &ti© &g&fl t y I! i iti ©f, fl t hi h t 1i ft th ity t© hi h h t © g 90. .1th© gh th it, &ti© ©f th ©th © - © iti iti ‘ h th i i by &fli 1 14 22 d 2? ©f th O tit' t fl hi h th ©f iti di id, &1 — th Sç ,i&1 R&pp t th&t & 1 i 1&ti tt h fld gi iti© t© th ight f© fl di ,id, &1 ©f hi t 1i ft th ity t© hi h h a 91. t© i© th Sç ,i&1 R&pp t t© &tt ti© t© th f& t th&t th right t© 1igi© i i i ithfl ' th f k ©f flit ti© &11y t b1i h i t d& d fl th fi 1d ©f h,]! ! ight i 1' dfl g th 1991 t,1& &ti© © th ü ti© ©f p.11 ©fE/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .1 p g 11 Tht©1 d ©f ni li i &ti© b i © R 1igi© © P 1i f, d fl with th t t&ti© by th fl ! Rights O itt . 92 . Th f& t fl it g &l 11 9 ©f 20 JUy 199? th IO]! ! Right O itt th&t th fr k t© t© &d©pt ligi© t 1i f & ily t&il i th fr k t© & ligi© © t 1i f, i 1' dfl g th right t© pl& © ligi© © t 1i f with th © t© &d©pt &th i ti ‘i ? 11 & th right t© t&fl © ligi© © t 1i f. fl i 1 19 p &g &ph 2 ©f th Tht t i© 1 O ! t Ci ,il d E 1 it i 1 Rights i© th&t 1d th right t© © &d©pt & ligi© © t 1i f, i 1' dfl g th ©f th &t ©f phy i &1 f© © c l ti© t© c l t 1i © © -t 1i t© t© ligi© t 1i ft d t© th i ligi© t 1i f t© / t ImI/GnT/ 1/R .1 . 5 9?. cflth t© th p1 t&ti© ©f th 1 i 1&ti© d p li y fl d t© th p1 E/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .1 p g 11 th d ;& i ty ©f I !d t if t j itflt Th p fl th fi 1d ©f i, &ti© , d ç ,i&lly fl fl © ity h 1 th Sç ,i&l R&pp t fr k ©f © th t dfl'g th&t this h fld ©thi© 1y ©t t i j fl t© it 99. cflth t© g i&l p=t fl th &ti©: 1 t b1i ©f © iti th Sç ,i&l R&pp t th&t & © t h fld t t k ©f th ç ,i&l ©f fl © ity h fl hi h h fld t fl t i fl th fr 99. M © iti h fld ©11 b &t l© ly fl th f© ,fl&ti© ©f &ti©: 1 th © gh itt 100. Th th p ©f i© 1 fi 1& fl &dditi© t© th fr th fl 'i t &t i© th Sç , rn R&pp t with flit ti© 11y t d& d &tt ti© t© &ni 1 4 ©f th 1991 r;1& &ti© : .11 St&t h 11 t k ff ,ti t© p t d di i &ti© th g © d ©f ligi© t 1i f fl th J it i© i d © t ©f h,]! ! right d f d t&1 fr k fl 11 fi 1d ©f i il p 1iti &1 ,rn d ,flt, &1 1if . OT tly. h th ü ti© ©f th ©b1ig&ti© f© th ©f g y h©p t© fl di &t th fr ligi© &ffii&ti© th fr© t ©f th fr h©p 101. Th th J' di i&1 t© . th Sç ,i&l R&pp t t© t b t th f© &ti© i i di li i &t©w t &t t © th p fl ©f J , dg h© tli h d & i it© di i© &g&fl t ©f © iti . Th this th Sç ,i&l R&pp t th&t it 1d t &pp ©p i&t t© &pply th ©f &th!i ©w ©f th c _ t f© W]! ! Rights th p , ifl g p t E/clT .4/1995/91 p &. 116) . t &flU! g ©f J , di rn d. fl g &l ç © l fl h,]! ! ight p i 'fl& 1y with t© t©1 d © -di ü ti© b i 1igi© t 1i f, 1d t higray &pp ©p i&t . 102 . Th it , &t i© ©f th S i M 1 i! i ity ©t t© gi t© p ©b1 ©f ligi© &t, pt fl ©f ©f hip. th&t ,ti© . th Sç ,i&1 R&pp t th&t fr k ©f pl& ©f hip h fld t d th&t th ©f h fld ©f th fr fl with th fr . th ti© ©f th d t ti© ©f ©f hip. th ity th h fld t ‘flt i t f© y di i ' i t k th&t ç&t©fl, y t t &ti &11y p1 j — 10?. pt f© i© p ©b1 fl ç ,ifi fi 1d with t© hi h th Sç ,i&1 R&pp t , d&ti© th it, &ti© ©f th i i M 1li d © iti &pç & t© t f&ifly ti f& t©w. 104. c hil ,&llfl g th f& t th&t th © iti d© ©t ! t t© t 1©it i p 1iti &11y fl t &w t© th ©f th Sc , i 1 R&pp t fl hi &p ity i d ç d t T t !pp t th i d i f© di 1 with th & th© iti fl hi &p ity Sç ,i&1 R&pp t ©f th O i i© Rights i1 fl withE/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .2 p g 2? hi d&t ‘igil t b t d t fl th fr it, &ti© fl th fi 1d ©f t©1 d © -di ü ti© b i © ligi© © t 1i f. 105. Th Sç ,i&l R&pp t t© hi b t th ©th I d Pt t t © ItI hil I fl g d l fl g th ; t fI t dI &tI© ©f fl fI 1d 106. cflth t© th I th Sç ,I&l R&pp t h©ç th&t dI t_tI© i1 t tI© ©f t 1I f d ©th tI© ©f & p 1ItI &1 If th 1&ttE/clT .4/1996/95/ dd .1 p g 24 11 ?. O 'fl g th Ptt t th Sç ,i&l R&pp t th&t th 1 1 ©f ligi© & ,i&ti© i 1' dfl g th m'i ,1 ch, h, h fld t 1& ifi i th © gh h biit&ti© . 114. Th Pt t t iti h fld t b1 t© g&g fl th fr ligi© & ti ,iti f'fll fr k( pt t i ti© & p © dd j f© fl i t ti© 11y t d& d . T© th&t d. th Sç ,i&l R&pp t th&t th b © th Th1 S ,i ty ©f I ! d © th G d ©f / g li h fld t 1ift i d th&t fr k t© p fl t d di u t ligi© pb1i &ti© i 1' dfl g th h fld t f,flly 115. O th ç ,ifi ti© ©f ©f hip d th t©, th Sç ,rn R&pp t t © g1y th&t 11 b ! d t i ti© h fld t 1ift i. Th © d' t ©f — th l g, &g th fl h fld 1 © t 1 ft ti 1y t© th di ti© ©f th ©f ligi© h© h fld t b1 t© g&g fl th fr ligi© & ti ,iti d th fr ©f itnt t fl g t© !‘y 116. Lk i with t© p © 1yti © i© d &p t& y , th Sç ,i&l R&pp t th t© flit ti© &11y t d& d fl th fi 1d ©f h,]! ! ight i 1' dfl g fr k t© ligi© d fr k t© ! if t ligi© t 1i f, ith fl di 'id' &1ly © fl ity with ©th d fl pth1i © p i /&t . b i! g t i ti© p © id i f© by Th f& t th © i© ©f M 1i! t© th ligi© h fld fl © &y gi t© b ! © t i ti© © th Pt t t ity, © th © © ©f ligi© . 117. Th Sç ,i&l R&pp t ©t th t &] &ti by th ©f pt t t p t© hQ & ©f th fr ity ©f t©1 d © -di ü ti© b i © ligi© © t 1i f h th t © g f 1fl g t© hi h th© g& Rg& d1 ©f th ti / f© th© u 1 & t th Sç ,i&l R&pp t t © g1y th d ly h©ç th&t ‘ h i1 ©t © th&t th Pt t t ity, 11 11 th ©th iti 1i f'flly itnt p l i© 119. L. t1y, th Sç ,i&l R&pp t th fi t ig ©f fi 1d d fl 1 , dfl g fr k ©f © &g it i© t© 11 th ight fl th i©: 1 h,]! ! right ! t ]! t lT©t Th d y ©-ch 1d i iti fl p ti ,fl& th onh t, c th©1i d pt t t © iti & 11 V s h&p. I . . ? . p &. 17 hi h th ply by th M i t F© ig ff&i
Download Attachments: